Is the “Tank” Over For the San Diego Padres?

Credit: USA Today

Spread the love
Source: Cliff McBride/Getty Images North America

The “tank” has been a buzz-word utilized by Padre fans for the 2017 season.

Most of which, at least to start the season, were in agreement that it would be acceptable if the Friars lost 100 games and had a shot at the top draft pick, dropping themselves to the bottom of the baseball “fish tank” if you will.

My definition of “tanking” means the Padres are to make no concerted effort to win games and perhaps be bad on purpose.

I am not sure the Padres consciously did that in 2017. If they did indeed try to tank, they were horrible at it. They didn’t even finish last in their own division (haha, Giants) and actually won 71 games.

There is a lot of chatter now that winter meetings have started about A.J. Preller and the Padres being very active.


By my definition, that doesn’t sound like a team that is “tanking” if the Padres are “thinking big” and wanting to get “top (free agents).” This begs the question: Is the tank over for the San Diego Padres? Is this the point where the organization digs their feet in deeper, to stop sliding backwards, and begins to push forward at the major league level? Keep in mind, this team is only two seasons removed from one of the most hyped and disappointing seasons in franchise history (2015). Preller punted and began a rebuild that has been in place for the past two seasons.

A team that is looking to spend triple-digit-millions on a free agent in Eric Hosmer, as Scott Boeck referenced above and A.J. Cassavell says below, is not a team that is looking towards a younger, brighter future. What are the Padres’ goals in 2018? Is A.J. Preller ready to try this again?

Certainly, the current roster looks to be in no position to compete, especially with the addition (for now) of a recycled Chase Headley. In addition, the most prized pieces of this “tank” (Fernando Tatis Jr., Luis Urias, Cal Quantrill, Mackenzie Gore) are not even close to being major league ready, much less ready to help the Padres win games.

San Diego also seems interested in not only acquiring a controllable shortstop, but willing to sacrifice a young starting pitcher to do so.

I feel like Padres fans are like the seagulls in “Finding Nemo” when it comes to the possible moving of top prospects, “Mine! Mine! Mine!” Understandably so, as the Friars have one of the most enviable farm systems in all of baseball. It looks like perhaps no one is safe. The Padres look to be gunning for Zack Cozart or even Freddy Galvis. Neither one would be an Erick Aybar, Alexei Ramirez-type shortstop acquisition. That would be a “we want our shortstop to help us win games” kind of move.

This is A.J. Preller we are talking about. He marches to the beat of his own drum, sometimes to a fault. By the definition of “tanking” I gave above, and if these rumors are true about how active the Padres are during winter meetings, the tank is over. 2018 is about winning ball games. That might be the message Preller is sending us.

Now, knowing him, he could make half a dozen moves in the next few weeks to make this article irrelevant and you will see tweets like “the tank is back on!” or “embrace the tank!” However, if this trend continues, Preller has no intention of tanking in 2018.

6 thoughts on “Is the “Tank” Over For the San Diego Padres?

  1. To be accurate, AJ has never stated that his intention was/is to tank .. I for one am interested to see how it plays out. Trading one pitching prospect for a proven MLB SS is not going to kill our pitcher rich system either (in fact, that’s why there are so many pitchers .. they’re valuable). Whatever moves are made, I’m confident that they will be made with the next 5+ seasons in mind

  2. Buying big names is not AJ’s strength, as history shows us. Ryan Mitchell is an excellent example of the kind of deal he excels at. Let Balsley work with a healthy and determined Mitchell, and chances are good he will blossom in a park like Petco. Then flip him at trade time during the season for some prospects. Then wait, and hope, like we all are now.

    1. Butch: I think most Padres fans are like you; willing to wait another year without mortgaging our financial future.

  3. If Preller and Co. trade any guys the top 10, no top 15, it will be a real head scratcher. 2015 and the flashy moves were a bust, stay the course AJ, us true fans can wait a couple more years. If it came down to overpaying for Hosmer or dealing a top prospect, I would be asking where to back up the Brinks truck.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *